In recent years, there has been a spate of papers and books asserting the similarities and compatibilities between deweyan pragmatism and confucianism. Confucianism was one of the dominant political philosophies of imperial china. Feminist interpretations of richard rorty a discussion of issues raised by richard rorty s engagement with feminist philosophy. This last great chinese neoconfucian movement is also know as the school of. Confucianism, also known as ruism, is a system of thought and behavior originating in ancient. On richard rorty hope is often associated with religion, but in rorty it was adamantly and unrepentantly secular.
Perspectives on rorty and brandom oslo, norway, 2829 october 2010 theme in connection with a visit of professor yajun chen nanjing university, the nordic pragmatism network and the university of oslo will arrange a workshop on neo pragmatism. Huang offers a fascinating dialogue between confucianism, historically the dominant tradition in chinese thought and society, and the contemporary philosophy of richard rorty. However, this does not mean that confucianism has no resources for a broadly construed notion of human dignity. It is both a history of philosophy text, highlighting deweys thought and subsequent pragmatist scholars, liberalism, and confucianism, and a polemic about the. We shall read rorty and also warren frisinas analysis of the problem in analytic philosophy that pragmatism with help from process philosophy and confucianism can help resolve. Rorty, berlin, and the confuciandaoist complementarity rorty, pragmatism, and confucianism with responses by richard rorty 2009.
The first of the books three sections samples pragmatism s religious roots. Pdf thinking through confucius download read online free. This comprehensive introduction explores the life and teachings ofconfucius, and development of confucian thought, from ancient timesto the present today. Stanford libraries official online search tool for books, media, journals, databases, government documents and more. Includes essays about the relevance for feminism of pragmatism, philosophy, rhetoric, realism, and liberalismprovided by publisher. Provocatively transcending boundaries between philosophy and theology, ancient and contemporary, east and west. Rorty 1998 is a short, interesting, if somewhat partisan, account of pragmatism s development up to the neopragmatist revival. This chapter examines the most controversial religious themes in the analects, namely confucius views on the existence and nature of. With responses by richard rorty suny series in chinese philosophy and culture huang, yong on. Religious thought and practice in the analects springerlink. Wildcard searching if you want to search for multiple variations of a word, you can substitute a special symbol called a wildcard for one or more letters. Rorty s own books are being rapidly translated and published in chinese, and from the great enthusiasm shown during rorty s monthlong lecture tour in. Goodman 1995 is an introductory essay to an edited collection but provides a useful overview with some emphasis on the neopragmatists broadening of pragmatism. Ui press edited by stuart rosenbaum pragmatism and.
Pragmatism was developed by americans such as charles sanders peirce,2 william james, and john dewey in the early twentieth century as a corrective to the western enlightenment tradition and its practice of philosophy that largely. Consider the practical effects of the objects of your conception. Guide to further reading primary works for a complete bibliography of rorty s writings through 2005, see eduardo mendieta ed. Contribution to book coping with incommensurable pursuits. I propose another version of pluralism in light of confucianism, which extends the concerns from the realm of language to the realm of experience i call it. Offers a comprehensive introduction to richard rortys life and body of work brings key essays published across many volumes and journals into one collection, including selections from his. Additional works that contain primary material by rorty. Rorty seems to think that the criterion of pragmatism, action, is the cashout sort of thing that hinges on the whimsy of our belief. An engagement between confucianism and the philosophy of richard rorty. Here i think the question of commensurability between early confucianism and rorty s brand of pragmatism can be raised again. Yao hsinchung reports that still other scholars hold the pragmatic view that the. Daoism, indigenous religiophilosophical tradition that has shaped chinese life. Rorty, confucius, and intercultural relativism kuangming wu on three contingencies in richard rorty. Some chinese intellectuals, like lu xun, attacked confucianism believing it to be one of the sources of chinas failure to modernize.
The great learning, the analects of confucius, the book of mencius and the doctrine of the mean. In this new millennium and global era, a new convergence of american pragmatism and asian confucianism may be well worth considering. His parents, james and winifred rorty, were activists, writers and social democrats. With responses by richard rorty suny series in chinese philosophy and culture by yong huang jan 1, 2010. As rorty states in his response, he does not value the virtue of harmony, either in the self or in the cosmos, and finds no cash value in using terms like the universe or the world in totalistic ways. James tartaglia, did rortys pragmatism have foundations. Well aware that his philosophical hero, john dewey, has had a lasting influence among chinese intellectuals, rorty expressed a wish that his own books, which have been rapidly translated into chinese, be read as an updated version of deweys philosophy. Provocatively transcending boundaries between philosophy and theology, ancient and contemporary, east and west, natural theology reconfigured revitalises the validity and relevancy of natural theology, a shipwrecked concept in the west, with the aid of eastern confucian axiology and american pragmatism. Confucianism s influence declined throughout the 19 th century coinciding with the end of the qing dynasty in 1911. While china has always had a diversity of religious beliefs, filial piety has been common to almost all of them. Yong huang is professor of philosophy at kutztown university and the author of religious goodness and.
The four books and five classics are the authoritative books of confucianism in china written. For example, world war ii with quotes will give more precise results than world war ii without quotes. Because heaven has laid down what is the way to perfect virtue, it is not that difficult to follow the steps of the holy rulers of old if one only. Classic of poetry or book of songs is the earliest anthology of chinese poems and songs. Pragmatism and religion addresses an important but overlooked issue. Lu chihs confucian pragmatist approach to the midtang predicament albany. A new name for some old ways of thinking by william james, philosophy and the mirror of nature by richard m. Pragmatism is a philosophical tradition that began in the united states around 1870. Phrase searching you can use double quotes to search for a series of words in a particular order. Neoconfucian philosophy internet encyclopedia of philosophy. The cultures and eras in which confucianism and pragmatism gestated and thrived were very different. According to yale university, the sacred texts of confucianism are five books that legend states confucius wrote. The philosopher responds to his critics the vanderbilt library of american philosophy.
Review andrew lambert 2012 philosophy east and west 62 1. Under the influence of the linguistic turn in philosophy, contemporary western philosophers typically limit their thinking on pluralism to the realm of language. Presumably, richard rorty s brand of neo pragmatism, which he considered to be a kind of critical footnote 2003, p. It is described as a modernist literary intellectuals project of fashioning the best possible self through continual redescription. In connection with a visit of professor yajun chen nanjing university, the nordic pragmatism network and the university of oslo will arrange a workshop on neo pragmatism. The first comprehensive collection of the work of richard rorty 19312007, the rorty reader brings together the influential american philosophers essential essays from over four decades of writings. Rorty, pragmatism, and confucianism, a collection of twelve essays on the work of richard rorty and its relation to confucian thought, arose out of a conference in shanghai in 2004, where participants were granted access to several of rorty s unpublished manuscripts. The five classics consists of the book of odes, book of documents, book of changes, book of rites, and the spring and autumn annals. In his introduction, the editor yong huang states his desire to outline areas of shared interest in rortian and confucian thought. Why be moral learning from the neoconfucian cheng brothers ebook written by yong huang. From the confucian perspective, it is easy to distinguish shustermans neoneopragmatism from rorty s neo pragmatism which remains bound to the socalled linguistic turn of modern philosophy. Neopragmatism, language and culture nordic pragmatism. Demonstrates the wisdom and enduring relevance ofconfuciuss teachings drawing parallels between our21st century society and that of china 2,500 years ago,where government corruption, along. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext.
With responses by richard rorty ebook written by yong huang. Dissimilarities between deweyan pragmatism and confucianism sfu. Since the enlightenment, nature has ceased to be a vital topic in theological discussions until a recent revival of interest stemming from ecological and feminist concerns. Then, your conception of those effects is the whole of your conception of the object. His critics often declared that the irony he championed, a way of holding ones beliefs lightly, was the posture of an elitist. Classic natural theology in its logical, rational, aristotelian presentation has encountered an impasse. In this book, twelve authors such as roger ames, chungying cheng, and so on engage rorty s. This sort of pluralism can be named as pluralism of significance. Well aware that his philosophical hero, john dewey, has had a lasting influence among chinese intellectuals, rorty. Richard rorty was born on october 4, 1931, in new york city.
It is thus interesting to see that rorty asks that his own. In the 12th century, zhu xi codified the sacred texts of confucianism, calling them simply the four books. An independent bookseller in hyde park serving readers locally and worldwide. The rorty reader general philosophy subjects wiley. Most contemporary interpreters of the analects agree that the text presents a religious perspective or, at the very least, that the text has religious aspects, but scholars have taken diverse positions on what kind of religious perspective that is. Pragmatism may 30, 2011 gene veith patheos explore the worlds faith through different perspectives on religion and spirituality. Such arguments for pragmatic political theory and even an appeal to the. The theme of the workshop is richard rorty s and robert brandoms views on. These books are the book of history, the book of poetry, the book of changes, the book of rites, and the spring and autumn annals. Its origins are often attributed to the philosophers charles sanders peirce, william james, and john dewey. From this rorty makes pragmatic reality, meaning, and truth a. The theme of the workshop is richard rorty s and robert brandoms views on world culture and language, emphasizing their commonalities and differences. Rorty, pragmatism, and confucianism 2010 edited by y. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read why be moral learning from the.
881 452 638 100 1406 203 66 1189 1116 1225 1252 743 542 872 1428 8 1573 695 34 983 856 320 1450 553 1434 95 1270 1267 926 48 1274 687 1415 907 107 1328 829 568 820 1059 840 518